Pumpkin Dump Cake Recipe – So Easy, So Cozy, So Good

You ever have one of those recipes that just… shows up in your life and quietly becomes a tradition? This pumpkin dump cake is that for me. It’s not fancy. It’s not pretty. But I swear, people lose their minds over it. It’s soft, warm, a little crunchy on top, and tastes like someone baked a sweater into a dessert.

It’s the first thing I bake when the mornings turn cold and the leaves start doing that thing where they crunch under your boots. It’s stupid-easy, takes almost no effort, and somehow feels like love in a pan.

Table of Contents

Why Pumpkin Dump Cake Has a Place in Every Fall

This started with a can of pumpkin and a grandma who didn’t do exact measurementsKitchen

I don’t even remember how old I was, maybe six, maybe eight, but I was standing on a stepstool in my grandma’s kitchen. She was wearing her old apron that had a weird stain on it that nobody ever talked about, and she handed me a can of pumpkin and said, “Just dump it in.”

That’s how I learned about dump cakes. No mixing bowls for dry and wet. No stand mixer. Just dump, layer, bake, eat.

She didn’t really explain what we were making, just that “everyone always loves this one.” And they did. I still remember the smell, warm sugar, nutmeg, cinnamon, butter, and how I tried to sneak bites before it had cooled. She swatted at me with a wooden spoon but let me take one anyway. It burned my tongue and it was worth it.

It’s not fancy, but it never lasts more than a day in my house

I’ve made this so many times since then, and it still hits every time. I’ve brought it to potlucks, dropped it off for new parents, made it just for me on a Wednesday night when I needed something that tasted like comfort. It never fails.

And the best part? It’s wildly forgiving. Forgot to buy yellow cake mix? Use spice cake. No pecans? Skip ’em. Don’t feel like melting butter? Just slice it into little pats and throw it on top. You cannot mess this up. It’s like the recipe knows life gets busy and just wants to help.

I keep it in the same mental folder as my apple crisp bars, you know, the “I’ve got 10 minutes and need something that feels like home” kind of recipes. This one’s reliable, cozy, and deeply satisfying. Also? It’s even better the next day cold, straight from the pan with a spoon. Ask me how I know.

What You’ll Need for the Best Pumpkin Dump Cake

You Probably Have Most of This in Your Pantry Right Now

Here’s what I love about pumpkin dump cake, it doesn’t ask for anything fancy. No mixers, no weird ingredients, no secret steps. Just a few things you probably already have sitting in your kitchen, especially if you’ve stocked up on pumpkin “just in case” like I tend to do every September.

You’ll need:

• 1 can of pumpkin puree (not pie filling, just the plain stuff)
• 1 can of evaporated milk
• 4 eggs
• 1 ½ cups sugar
• A good spoonful of pumpkin pie spice
• A pinch of salt
• 1 box of yellow cake mix (spice cake also works if that’s your vibe)
• Chopped pecans (optional, but highly recommended)
• 1 cup of melted butter (yeah, it’s a lot, but it’s worth it)

That’s it. That’s all it takes to make a pumpkin dump cake that’ll have people hovering over the pan with a spoon pretending they’re just “cleaning up the edges.”

How to Put It All Together Without Overthinking It

This is the part where you’ll want to resist every instinct to mix things up like a regular cake. I know it feels weird, but that’s kind of the point. Dump cakes are all about layers, and not in a fussy way. More like a “dump it and trust the process” kind of way.

Here’s how I do mine:

First, preheat your oven to 350°F and grease your 9×13 pan. Or just spray it with whatever nonstick spray you’ve got. No judgment here.

In a big bowl, whisk together the pumpkin, evaporated milk, eggs, sugar, pumpkin pie spice, and salt. This is your filling, the cozy, spiced base that makes this more than just some cake-mix dessert.

Pour that filling into your greased pan and smooth it out.

Now, and this part feels wrong, but just go with it, take the dry cake mix and sprinkle it right on top. No mixing, no stirring. Just shake it out like you’re covering a casserole with breadcrumbs or something.

Toss on the chopped pecans, and then drizzle your melted butter over everything. You can also just slice cold butter and dot it across the top if you’re feeling lazy. I’ve done both. They both work.

Once that’s done, you pop it in the oven and let it do its thing. And while it bakes, your whole house is going to smell like warm spices, sweet pumpkin, and actual happiness. You’ll probably text someone just to say “it smells like fall in here.”

This pumpkin dump cake never takes more than ten minutes to throw together, but it tastes like one of those desserts people will think you really tried on. I’ve made it for friends, potlucks, rainy Sundays, and one very chaotic Thanksgiving where it completely saved dessert.

Honestly? I trust this recipe more than I trust most adult humans. It always turns out.

Baking Your Pumpkin Dump Cake to That Just-Right Sweet Spot

How Long to Bake It (And What “Done” Actually Looks Like)

Alright, so your pumpkin dump cake is all layered and ready to go. You’ve resisted the urge to stir (good job), and now it’s just a matter of letting your oven do its thing.

I usually bake mine at 350°F for somewhere between 60 and 75 minutes. I know that’s kind of a window, but every oven is its own little weirdo. Some run hot, some run slow, and this cake is kind of a middle child, it takes its time.

Here’s what you’re looking for: the top should be golden brown and maybe a little bubbly around the edges. It should smell like pumpkin spice and toasted butter and happiness. The center will still have a soft, pie-like texture, don’t expect it to firm up like a regular cake.

If you’re unsure, you can gently poke a knife into the middle and see if it comes out mostly clean. Not bone dry, but not dripping. Think soft set, like pumpkin pie. That’s your sweet spot.

Let it cool for at least 15–20 minutes before serving. I know it’s hard, but trust me, you’ll burn your tongue if you rush it (ask me how I know). Plus, the flavors settle a little as it cools, and the texture gets that perfect contrast: soft and custardy underneath, crisp and buttery on top.

Now the Important Question: How Do You Serve It?

Here’s the short answer: any way you want.

I’ve served this pumpkin dump cake warm with a scoop of vanilla ice cream melting into the crevices. I’ve done cold with whipped cream from a can (because I was tired and it was still amazing). I’ve eaten it straight from the pan with a spoon while standing at the counter and pretending I was “just tasting.”

All of these ways are correct.

If you’re making this for a group, Thanksgiving, a potluck, family dinner, definitely go the warm plus ice cream route. It gets those big “you made this?!” reactions. But don’t be afraid to just keep it casual. Pumpkin dump cake doesn’t judge. It’s good warm, it’s good cold, it’s good for breakfast if you’re into that sort of thing (I am).

And hey, if you’re like me and love your fall desserts buttery and a little indulgent, this one checks every box. It’s that just-right mix of comfort food and shortcut brilliance, and no one has to know it came from a box mix and a can.

How to Store Pumpkin Dump Cake (And What to Do If It Gets Weird)

Leftovers? Ha. Good luck with that.

Okay. So let’s pretend, just for fun, that you didn’t eat half the pan standing at the counter. Let’s say you’ve got some pumpkin dump cake left.

Cover it up, foil, plastic wrap, whatever you’ve got, and toss it in the fridge. It’ll last 3 or 4 days, easy. But honestly, it probably won’t make it past tomorrow. Every time you walk by, you’ll be like, “Just one bite…” and then suddenly the corner’s gone and you’re scraping the edge with a fork. It’s fine. We’ve all been there.

If you want it warm again (which, yes), microwave a scoop for 30 seconds and you’re golden. Or heat it slow in the oven if you’re being fancy. Either way, still hits. Still cozy. Still smells like you tried harder than you actually did.

Also? Cold. Straight from the fridge. Fork. Pajamas. Midnight. Life-changing.

Can you make it ahead? Oh yeah.

This pumpkin dump cake is not high-maintenance. Bake it the day before, let it hang out in the fridge, warm it up when you’re ready. Easy. It actually gets better after sitting, like it pulls itself together overnight.

If your oven’s full with other stuff (been there), just mix the pumpkin filling ahead of time, stash it in the fridge, and dump everything together right before baking. Ten-minute job, max.

What if it comes out weird?

First of all, it’s probably still awesome.

But just in case:

• Too wet in the middle? Give it more time. It’s not cake-cake. The middle should be soft, not soupy. Every oven’s got attitude, so check again in 10 minutes.
• Top looks weird? Good. Dump cakes aren’t supposed to be cute. Embrace the chaos. It’s about taste, not looks.
• No crunch? That’s probably margarine’s fault. Use real butter. The full cup. Yes, it’s a lot. That’s why it’s good.
• Forgot the pecans? So what? No one’s crying. Still tastes like fall.

Look, this pumpkin dump cake is not here to impress your judgy cousin or win a bake-off. It’s here to make your house smell amazing and your day 10 times better. It’s the kind of dessert you make when you want something warm and buttery and don’t feel like dealing with anything complicated.

So yeah. Whether it’s Thanksgiving or Tuesday or just that moment when you realize you’ve had a can of pumpkin in the pantry since last year, this cake’s got you. No stress. Just dump it, bake it, eat it. Done.

Conclusion: Just Make the Cake

If you’re still here, still reading… just make the pumpkin dump cake.

Seriously. Don’t overthink it. Don’t wait for the “right” day or a holiday or a clean kitchen. It doesn’t care. This cake is one of those rare things that’s low effort, high comfort. It’s warm and soft and a little crunchy on top, and it just feels good.

You dump some things in a pan, throw it in the oven, and somehow end up with something that tastes like you tried harder than you did. No mixer. No crust. No stress.

Make it because it’s Tuesday. Or because you’ve had a weird week. Or because someone’s coming over and you want your house to smell like you have your life together (even if you don’t). Or just because there’s a can of pumpkin staring at you from the pantry and you’re tired of pretending it’s not there.

This pumpkin dump cake? It’s got your back.

Print

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use spice cake instead of yellow?

Absolutely. I’ve done it plenty of times, especially when I forget what I originally planned to buy. Spice cake brings more fall energy, yellow cake keeps it simple and buttery. You really can’t mess it up. Go with whatever’s in the cabinet.

Is this like pumpkin pie?

A little. But honestly, easier and more fun to eat. It’s got the soft, cozy pumpkin filling like pie does, but instead of crust, you get this golden, slightly crispy topping that tastes like it came from a bakery. It’s pie’s cooler, more chill cousin.

Can I make it ahead?

Totally. I usually do. It holds up great. You can make it the night before and heat it up later, or just serve it cold, straight from the fridge, no shame. It’s good no matter what, and it actually gets better after it’s had some time to settle.

What if it doesn’t look perfect?

Then you nailed it. Pumpkin dump cake isn’t supposed to look perfect. It’s supposed to taste amazing. If the top is uneven, or the middle’s a little soft, or the pecans went rogue, it’s fine. It’s real. You’re feeding people, not photographing it for a magazine. Grab a spoon.