Pumpkin Sugar Cookies with Cream Cheese Frosting Recipe

Pumpkin sugar cookies taste like fall, plain and simple. They’re soft, a little spiced, and the frosting… honestly, that’s the part that gets me. Creamy, tangy, sweet, I could eat it straight out of the bowl. This isn’t some complicated recipe. It’s the kind of thing you make on a chilly afternoon when the oven makes the whole house smell warm and safe. For me, these cookies aren’t just dessert. They’re a memory. Flour on the counter, pumpkin on my hands, my grandma humming while I “helped.” That’s what I think of every single time I make them.

Table of Contents

Part 1: The Story Behind Pumpkin Sugar Cookies

A Family Memory in Every Bite

I remember dragging a chair across my grandma’s kitchen floor, the scrape so loud she’d yell, “Careful with my linoleum!”, and climbing up just high enough to see into the bowl. She’d already started the butter and sugar, and it smelled sweet and heavy in the air. She’d let me dump in the pumpkin, even though half of it ended up on the counter. Didn’t matter. She just smiled and stirred, slow and steady, like nothing could ruin it.

When the cookies came out, warm and golden, she’d hand me a butter knife and a bowl of cream cheese frosting. I’d glob it on thick, lick the knife, and glob some more. She never stopped me. She just laughed. Those cookies weren’t perfect, some crooked, some too frosted, some barely touched, but they were ours. To this day, making them feels the same as pulling out her classic peach cobbler: messy, a little chaotic, and worth every second.

Why They Belong in Fall Baking

Pumpkin sugar cookies don’t pretend to be fancy. They’re not the kind of thing you put in a bakery window. But put a plate of them on the table, and they’re the first to go. The pumpkin keeps them soft, the spices smell like home, and the frosting makes people close their eyes when they take that first bite. That’s all you need.

I bake them when the air turns sharp and the leaves start crunching underfoot. Sometimes I’ll have a pumpkin crisp cooling on the counter too, because in my world there’s no such thing as too much pumpkin. But these cookies? They’re the ones people reach for with their hands still warm from their coffee mug. They’re the ones that taste like fall.

Ingredients That Make Pumpkin Sugar Cookies Special

The Role of Each Ingredient

Every cookie tells on itself by the ingredients you choose. With these pumpkin sugar cookies, nothing’s wasted. Here’s how each one matters:

Ingredient	What It Brings	Human Tip
Butter	Soft, rich texture	Room temp, never melted
Granulated Sugar	Sweetness and structure	Cream it long enough for fluff
Brown Sugar	Moisture and caramel notes	Dark brown = deeper flavor
Pumpkin Puree	Moisture + flavor	Use plain puree, not pie filling
Spices	Cinnamon, nutmeg, cloves	Fresh spices = stronger flavor
Cream Cheese Frosting	Sweet tangy finish	Beat until smooth & fluffy

Tips for Better Cookies

Here’s the truth: the recipe is simple, but the little things make it work. I’ve learned most of these the hard way:

• Pumpkin: It must be pure pumpkin puree. Pumpkin pie filling looks tempting, but it’s already sweetened and spiced. That’ll mess everything up.
• Creaming butter + sugar: Don’t rush it. When you think it’s fluffy enough, keep going another minute. That air gives you soft cookies.
• Sticky dough: If it’s too tacky to scoop, pop it in the fridge for 10–15 minutes. It scoops cleaner, and your cookies bake more evenly.
• Cooling: This one’s hard, wait until the cookies are completely cool before frosting. I’ve given in to impatience, and the frosting just melts and slides off.

If you want to dress them up, you can. Add white chocolate chips, sprinkle chopped pecans, or even drizzle melted white chocolate over the frosting once it sets. I’ve put them out next to a pumpkin bundt cake and pumpkin chocolate chip bars at family gatherings, and they always vanish first.

And here’s my favorite part: they don’t have to be perfect. Uneven frosting, a little crumb here and there, that’s what makes them feel homemade.

How to Bake Pumpkin Sugar Cookies

First thing? Oven on. Don’t skip it. Set it to 350°F right away because nothing’s worse than sliding cookies into a cold oven and pulling out flat little pancakes. Learned that one when I was too impatient. While it heats, grab a couple baking sheets and line them with parchment. It feels unnecessary until you’re scrubbing stuck cookie bottoms off a pan.

Next, the butter and sugar. This part takes some patience. You can’t just stir it until it looks mixed, you’ve got to beat it until it’s fluffy. Like, really fluffy. If your arm gets sore, that means you’re getting close. That’s the secret to soft cookies.

Now add the pumpkin, yolk, and vanilla. I’ll warn you, it looks kind of gross at first, like it’s separating. That’s fine. The flour will fix it. In a smaller bowl, whisk together your flour, baking powder, salt, and spices. Do it separately or you’ll end up with little clumps of cinnamon hiding in your cookies, and nobody wants that. Slowly add the dry stuff into the wet. Stir just until the flour’s gone. Stop there. I know it’s tempting to keep stirring until it looks extra smooth, but that’s how you get tough cookies.

Time for the fun part, scooping. A spoon works, but if you’ve got a cookie scoop, use it. Drop the dough onto your pans and don’t crowd them. They spread just enough to nudge into each other if you’re careless, and then you’ve got one giant cookie. Not that a giant cookie is the worst problem in the world, but still.

Bake them for 10 to 12 minutes. Don’t trust the clock, though, look at them. The edges should look set, and the tops shouldn’t be shiny anymore. That’s your cue. Pull them out and let them sit right on the pan for a few minutes. If you try to move them too soon, they’ll fall apart in your hands. I’ve eaten them like that plenty of times, warm, crumbly, messy, and honestly, it’s hard to beat. But if you want to frost them, you’ve got to wait until they’re fully cool.

By the time they’re cooling on the rack, your kitchen smells like cinnamon, butter, and pumpkin. That’s when people start hovering. If you want to actually frost all of them, make a double batch. Otherwise, half will be gone before you even get the cream cheese out.

Frosting, Serving, and Storage

Making the Frosting Without Overthinking It

The frosting’s the fun part. It’s really nothing fancy, just cream cheese, a little butter, powdered sugar, vanilla, and a pinch of salt. Start by beating the cream cheese and butter together until they’re completely smooth. If they’re still a little cold, you’ll be chasing lumps forever, so let them soften on the counter first. Then add the powdered sugar a little at a time, or you’ll be cleaning up a sugar cloud that floats across the kitchen. Stir in vanilla and that pinch of salt. Taste it. Always taste it. If it’s too sweet, add another tiny pinch of salt. If it feels too thick, a drop of milk loosens it right up.

Spread it thick or thin, however you like. I’ve never been good at neat swirls, and honestly, no one cares. They just want a cookie with enough frosting to leave a little on their fingers.

Serving and Storing the Cookies

Serve them once the frosting sets a little, or don’t wait, I never do. They’re the kind of cookie that disappears fast, so set some aside if you actually want leftovers. They sit beautifully next to other fall bakes, like pumpkin dump cake or pumpkin chocolate chip bars, but honestly, they don’t need any company.

Storing them couldn’t be easier, just tuck the cookies into an airtight container and pop them in the fridge. Because of the frosting, these cookies can’t just sit out on the counter for days. They’ll be good for about three days chilled. If you want to plan ahead, bake the cookies and freeze them unfrosted. They’ll keep for a couple months that way. Then just thaw, frost, and serve when you’re ready.

But let’s be honest, they never last long enough to need freezing. Around here, by the time I turn my back, half the batch is gone, and someone’s licking frosting off the spatula.

Wrapping It All Up

Pumpkin sugar cookies aren’t perfect little bakery cookies. Mine never match. Some are fat, some are thin, some end up with way too much frosting. And honestly? That’s why I love them. They taste homemade because they are.

They’re soft, spiced, and messy in the best way. And they carry memory with them. I can still picture myself in my grandma’s kitchen, standing on a chair, covered in flour, sneaking frosting before she noticed. Every batch I bake now takes me right back there.

Put them out with other fall favorites like pumpkin crisp or pumpkin bundt cake, and yours will be the first plate gone. Or skip the party, bake them just for yourself, and eat one warm off the rack before the frosting even touches it. Trust me, make two batches. The first one always disappears.

Print

Questions People Always Ask Me

How do you keep them soft?
It’s all about timing. Pull them out before you think they’re done. The edges should look set, and the tops shouldn’t be shiny anymore. That’s it. If you wait until they look “perfect,” they’ll be dry. And don’t skip beating the butter and sugar longer than feels necessary, it’s boring, I know, but that’s what makes them fluffy.

Can you freeze them?
Yes, but only the unfrosted cookies. I’ve tried freezing frosted ones, and it’s just… bad. They thaw into a soggy mess. Bake, cool, and freeze the plain cookies with parchment between them. Then when you’re ready, thaw, frost, and they’ll taste like fresh-baked.

Do you really need cream cheese frosting?
In my world, yes. Without it, they’re just pumpkin cookies, still good, but not the kind that makes people stop and close their eyes after the first bite. That tangy frosting is the magic.

Can I add chocolate chips or nuts?
Absolutely. White chocolate chips are lovely, pecans give a nice crunch, even mini chocolate chips work. Just don’t dump in too much, a handful is plenty. Too many extras and the dough doesn’t hold together.