Turkey Cupcakes Recipe ; Fun Thanksgiving Dessert Idea

Thanksgiving at my house is usually all about pies. Pumpkin, pecan, apple, you name it. But a few years ago I started making turkey cupcakes, and now they show up right alongside the pie. They’re silly, colorful, and honestly just fun to make. Kids love them, but so do the adults, I’ve seen grown folks carefully pick out the candy feathers like it’s serious business. The best part? You don’t need to be a cake decorator. These cupcakes are easy, forgiving, and a good excuse to get a little messy with frosting and candy. That’s what Thanksgiving should be about anyway.

Why I Love Making Turkey Cupcakes

A sweet Thanksgiving tradition

Thanksgiving at my house is always about the usual stuff. Turkey, stuffing, mashed potatoes, and of course, pie. Pumpkin, pecan, apple, always the same lineup. But a few years back I decided to shake it up and made turkey cupcakes. Not the big bird, cupcakes dressed up like little turkeys.

And you know what? They stuck. They’re goofy, colorful, and just plain fun. My nieces dive right in, candy eyes slipping sideways, feathers falling over, and nobody cares. We laugh, we eat, and it feels like the whole holiday softens a bit. I love the food traditions, but I also love breaking them just enough to make new ones.

Why cupcakes beat pie sometimes

Now don’t get me wrong, I’ll never skip pie. But pie takes work. Rolling dough, watching the crust, praying it sets right. Cupcakes? You bake, cool, frost, and you’re done. And if you’re short on time, you can even grab a box mix and nobody complains.

And here’s the funny part, when I put out a tray of turkey cupcakes, they get as much attention as the pie. Sometimes more. People don’t even wait for coffee; they just grab one. No fork needed. Kids go nuts for them. Grown-ups too, though they pretend they’re just “helping the kids.” It’s the easiest win on a crowded Thanksgiving table.

The Ingredients You’ll Need for Turkey Cupcakes

Simple cupcake base

You don’t need anything fancy to get these going. I usually make chocolate cupcakes because they look the most like little turkeys, but honestly, any flavor works. If you’re short on time, grab a box mix. No shame in that, I’ve done it plenty of times when the oven’s already full of stuffing and casseroles.

If you’re baking from scratch, the basics are flour, cocoa powder, sugar, butter, eggs. A little sour cream or yogurt makes the cupcakes moist. Nothing complicated. Just good, simple chocolate cake.

Buttercream and candy decorations

The real fun is in the frosting and the toppings. Chocolate buttercream makes the base look like the turkey’s body. Then you get to play dress-up. Mini Reese’s cups make perfect heads. Candy eyes stick right on with a dab of frosting. A bit of gummy worm works as the wattle. And for feathers? Reese’s Pieces lined up in rows, orange, brown, yellow. It looks more complicated than it is.

That’s the beauty of turkey cupcakes. You don’t need piping skills. You don’t need a steady hand. The candy does most of the decorating for you. Even if they come out a little crooked, they still look like turkeys, and everybody loves them anyway.

It’s the same reason I adore fun desserts like my pumpkin sugar cookies. They’re not about being perfect. They’re about smiling at the plate before you even take a bite.

How to Make Turkey Cupcakes Step by Step

Baking the cupcakes

The cupcakes are the easy part. If you’re using a mix, just follow the box. If you’re baking from scratch, it’s the usual drill, mix dry in one bowl, wet in another, bring it together. Don’t worry about being perfect; cupcakes are forgiving.

I use an ice cream scoop to fill the liners. Two-thirds full, and you’re set. Bake them until the house smells like chocolate and you can’t wait any longer, usually about twenty minutes. Then comes the hard part: letting them cool. Seriously, walk away if you have to, because if you frost too soon, it’ll all slide right off. Been there.

Decorating the cupcakes

This is where it gets fun. Spread on chocolate frosting, doesn’t need to be fancy, just cover the top. Press a mini Reese’s cup toward the front for the turkey head. Add candy eyes with a little frosting “glue.” Slice a gummy worm for the wattle, stick half an orange Reese’s piece on for the beak. Suddenly you’ve got a goofy little turkey face looking at you.

Now the feathers. Line Reese’s Pieces across the back. Orange, brown, yellow, whatever order you like. Sometimes mine lean or flop, but that’s part of the charm. By the end, you’ve got a flock of lopsided, colorful little turkeys. And honestly? They’re hilarious. Perfect for Thanksgiving, perfect for kids, perfect for anyone who could use a laugh with their dessert.

Serving, Storing, and Variations

Serving Turkey Cupcakes at Thanksgiving

Turkey cupcakes aren’t just dessert, they’re a centerpiece. I usually line them up on a big tray, and it looks like a little turkey parade right across the table. The kids go nuts picking “their turkey,” and the adults? They pretend it’s for the kids but they’re just as into it.

They don’t need forks or plates. People grab one, laugh at the goofy candy eyes, and take a bite. They’re the kind of thing that makes the whole table relax a little. Thanksgiving is heavy enough, these cupcakes bring the fun.

Storing and Freezing Cupcakes

If by some miracle you have leftovers, just tuck them into an airtight container. They’ll keep on the counter a couple of days, longer in the fridge. The candy softens up a bit in the fridge, but nobody seems to mind.

Freezing works too, but here’s the trick, freeze them plain. Cupcakes only. The frosting and candy don’t love the freezer, trust me. Thaw them later, decorate fresh, and they’ll look just as goofy and sweet.

And don’t feel locked into chocolate. Vanilla, peanut butter, even a swirl cupcake, all work. Swap candies if you want. I’ve made “turkeys” with M&Ms when that’s what I had. Still gone by the end of the night.

Wrapping It Up

Turkey cupcakes aren’t about being perfect. They’re about laughing at candy eyes that slide off, sneaking a Reese’s feather before dinner, and letting kids make a mess with frosting. They bring a little lightness to a holiday that can feel heavy with tradition.

Every time I make them, they disappear fast, sometimes before the pie even hits the table. That’s when I know they’re worth it. Simple, sweet, and fun. Exactly what Thanksgiving needs.

Print